|
The US equity markets, as
defined by the S&P 500 Equity Index, registered a rebound performance in
2009, after its disastrous 37% performance for 2008.
However, the
markets’ 2009 performance was, indeed exceptional, many investors still have
far to go to recoup their losses. This is underscored by the fact that although
an intuitive calculation of average portfolio returns might lead an investor to
believe that a portfolio sustaining a 37% loss in a given year and subsequently
achieving a 23.5% gain the next should have resulted in an average loss
of only 6.75% (-37+23.5/2 = - 6.75) for the two-year period.
Unfortunately, this is not
the case. The real loss would actually
be -22.2% because, although average
returns are valid for certain purposes, only annualized (and time-weighted
geometric) returns present an accurate picture of an investor’s true returns.
The annualized return for the S&P 500 for the 2008-2009 period is actually:
1-.37x 1.235-1.0 = -22.2%, which is the real loss for the S&P 500
for the two-year period. More
simplistically, if an investor loses 50% one year and gains 50% the next, the
investor is still down 25% at the end of the second year and for the
period.
The annualized figure
reflects the more accurate result and underscores the difference between
average returns and annualized returns. Portfolio returns should always be
stated in terms of annualized geometric time-weighted returns and should take
into consideration, mathematically, all additions, withdrawals and costs
incurred for the calculation period. This has always been and will continue to
be Wealth Conservancy International’s policy.
Historically, the average
returns of the S& P 500 from 1871-2008, inclusively, have been
approximately 10.5%, while the annualized returns have been approximately 8.8%
for the period. Inflation-adjusted, the returns are 8.3% and 6.6%,
respectively. Note that annualized returns are always lower than average
returns.
Market Forecast for 2010 and
Beyond
The recession has ended,
probably in the summer of 2009, and the economy is rebounding, albeit, it would
appear, somewhat slowly. Surface appearances may be misleading, however, as the
equity markets are continuing to signal a strong economic rebound in the not
too distant future. Wealth Conservancy is taking its cue from the equity
markets, one of the most accurate of the economic leading indicators.
Adding to our optimism, is
our analysis of previous market downturns, which indicates that, except for the
Great Depression years of 1929-1937, only once since the beginning of data
collection on the primary US equity market (in 1871) has the S&P 500, or
its predecessor, not made up for a single year’s market downturn within a
two-year time period. That failure to recoup a previous year’s losses occurred
in 1893. Except for that occurrence, on
an arithmetic basis, all single year losses have been followed by one or more
positive market years that have erased the loss over the following two years.
Although this trend may simply be coincidental or random (a much more rigorous
analysis is required for a determination of statistical significance to be
made), for the 2008 correction to be erased within a two-year time frame, the
S&P 500 would have to gain at least 13.5%
in 2010. Primarily, because of improving economic indicators and
principally because of our estimates of robust corporate earnings growth in
2010, Wealth Conservancy forecasts that this is exactly what will occur and
that the historical trend will again be reinforced in 2010.
Clearly, we believe that the
majority of Wall Street and International equity analysts’ forecasts for the US
markets will err on the downside in 2010.
Nevertheless, Wealth Conservancy believes that the most serious threat
to the US and world economies is the potential for another prolonged oil price
spike that might commence this summer. Absent this, we are likely to see a
vastly improved economic picture unfold over the next three years with US GDP
growth accelerating to 3.5-4% by this year’s end and with other major economies
reaping the benefits of a resurging US economy.
Trends and Opportunities
Wealth Conservancy sees
investment opportunities in nearly all equity sectors with the caveat that many
sectors’ prices have already been bid up significantly by institutions and
hedge funds, e.g. infrastructure building supplies and steel. For debt
securities, inflation-protected securities, intermediate term high-grade bonds
and well managed high yield bond funds offer the best prospects for superior
risk-adjusted returns. Global Real estate and commodities, except, we believe,
for gold bullion, also appear attractive investment options.
It is important, of course,
to adhere to the basics: allocate assets reasonably in accordance with each investor’s
tolerance for volatility risk, maintain diversification among and within asset
classes and include asset classes within the portfolio mix such as real estate,
commodities, inflation-protected securities and high-yield bonds that spread
risk, offer an income foundation and hedge against inflation. Insuring that
securities are not purchased at excessive prices based primarily on potentially
inflated earnings expectations must also be a part of one’s discipline, while
purchasing individual equity securities that offer attractive and reliable
dividend streams, as well as the potential for share-price appreciation also
generally makes good sense.
In fact this is Wealth
Conservancy International’s investment philosophy.
Going forward the following
individual securities appear to offer attractive potential: Applied Materials,
Oneok Partners and TORM Shipping.
Applied Materials (AMAT),
the semiconductor sector giant with a market cap of $19 B, can be purchased for
$14/share and provides a dividend of just under 2%. The firm has an
exceptionally strong balance sheet (2.0 quick ratio, 3.0 current ratio) and
operates with a gross margin of 40+%.
The firm’s earnings are on the upswing with peak earnings anticipated in
2011. Upgraded recently to “outperform” by FBC Capital, Applied Materials
appears to be an attractive investment at its current price.
Another attractive equity
investment is Oneok Partners (OKS), the fastest-growing energy company in the
world, according to the global energy experts, Platts. Ahead only 3% thus far
in 2010, the stock pays a 6.8% dividend that appears safe. Oneok, with a market
capitalization of just under $4 billion, has a horizontal business structure in
a very attractive business, the production, storage and transportation of
natural and liquefied natural gas in the United States. We believe that OKS has
excellent prospects for growth while, at the same time, yielding nearly 7%;
this is a hard combination to beat for the conservative investor.
Another investment that may
have potential is TORM Shipping, a Danish firm whose stock currently trades at
just under $13.00 at an 11P/E and that pays a 10+ % dividend. Having suffered a
lackluster 2009, we believe that the stock price will rebound commensurate with
a rebound in world trade, which we believe is already under way.
Mutual funds that look
attractive include the Cohen and Steers Infrastructure fund and their global real estate fund.
These securities provide diversification, a dividend yield of approximately 4%
and the opportunity to reap the advantages of a global upturn from very
depressed real estate prices.
Also, the Oppenheimer’s
strategic commodities fund also looks tactically auspicious because this
security’s index is highly correlated to petroleum prices and will provide
leveraged returns if, as we believe, petroleum prices rise appreciably later in
the year.
Inflation protected bond
fund exposure, for example with the Vanguard Inflation Protected mutual fund,
will also prove advantageous as a core holding over the next ten years. The
Vanguard fund returned nearly 11% in 2009, when inflationary pressures were
quiescent. Prices will very likely rise
in the future and inflation-protected securities are the best inflationary
hedge available in the market place.
Although Wealth Conservancy
International, Inc. does not advertise on the basis of performance, our average
client portfolio returned 34.5% and our median client portfolio return
was 29.3% in 2009. The performance range of clients for 2009 was 9.7%
to 49.2%.
Updated on February 8, 2010.
|